According to David Gussin, he created the everything bagel in the 1980s when he was a teenager, sweeping up after a day hard at work in a bagel shop in Queens, New York City. However, according to Seth Godin, these bagels were already in existence in 1977, since he was making them himself. No matter where exactly the everything bagel came from, it has swept the nation as a favorite flavor, with everything bagels being made in shops all over the country. Ingredients: Poppy seeds, garlic, sea salt, sesame, and onion.